We stood, about 20 in total, in the shade of a massive sandstone monolith gazing at Mesa Verde’s Cliff Palace. Here, some 700 years ago, ancestral Puebloans farmed, hunted, and traded amidst a vibrant civilization. Our tour guide drew a turkey bone flute from her pocket, and we listened as the sound washed over us, pulling an ancient thread that closed the distance between that world and this.
The summer of 2026 marked the 120th anniversary of the Antiquities Act and the nation’s 250th anniversary, even as it brought renewed threats to some of the nation’s most treasured public lands. The confluence of it all—the flute, the ruins, the anniversaries, and those threats—raise questions about the past, present, and future of preservation in the United States.
In the decades after the Civil War, millions of men and women—Americans and immigrants alike—poured into the American West. Most of them shared the belief that the West was theirs to take, a set of resources to exploit.
But the unchecked pursuit of material wealth brought damage that was impossible to deny.
Wanton logging sparked fears of a national timber famine. Hydraulic mining reduced mountains to mud and twisted pristine streams into bitter slurry that threatened farmers and salmon alike. And tens of millions of bison were nearly driven to extinction by hide hunters and military marksmen.
This intensity of exploitation—ghastly as it was—helped catalyze American conservation and the creation of the world’s first national park at Yellowstone in 1872. In a nation insecure about its cultural heritage, protecting Yellowstone and the big trees of California took on new significance.
We didn’t have an Acropolis, a Colosseum, or a great cathedral like Notre-Dame. But we had fantastic natural wonders that could speak to our national—if not cultural—heritage. Left unprotected, the gnashing teeth of progress would soon consume these, too.
Progressive-era reformers shared a conviction that government could—and should—do more. The only force powerful enough to check modern industrial capitalism was the government itself. No one fought for conservation more than the indefatigable Teddy Roosevelt.
Roosevelt traveled West at 24 to hunt bison and later spent two years ranching in the Dakota Territory. Harvard-educated, an ardent Progressive, and a self-styled westerner, he moved through New York politics before becoming governor, vice president, and, after William McKinley’s assassination in 1901, president.
Concern over the looting of Indigenous cultural heritage was nothing new when Roosevelt assumed the presidency. Archaeologists and anthropologists had spent decades pressing for the protection of ancient sites, with some success—notably at Casa Grande—set aside by executive order in 1892.
But protection remained slow and piecemeal.
Meanwhile, pot hunters were destroying Chaco Canyon, Mesa Verde, and countless other sites across the West and Southwest. Whether taken for profit or in the name of science, irreplaceable pieces of the nation’s past were slipping away. What was needed was legislative triage.
In 1902, Representative John F. Lacey and anthropologist Edgar Lee Hewett traveled to the Southwest to see the problem firsthand. With Lacey’s leadership and Hewett’s significant contributions to the language of the final bill, Congress passed—and Teddy Roosevelt signed—An Act for the Preservation of American Antiquities in 1906.
In two pages, the Act granted the president authority to establish national monuments protecting “historic landmarks, historic and prehistoric structures, and other objects of historic or scientific interest.” Roosevelt established 18 national monuments during the remainder of his presidency. In the 120 years since, presidents have used the Act nearly 300 times to protect places of cultural, historic, and environmental significance.
But the Act has always been controversial because of the very thing it sought to deliver—expeditious protection without consensus. Roosevelt tested its limits in 1908 by establishing Grand Canyon National Monument, protecting more than 800,000 acres with the stroke of his pen.
To supporters, treasured places could now be protected from development. But to opponents, the action demonstrated the danger of giving one president authority over vast stretches of the West. The tension between preservation and use, and between executive action and public consensus, was baked into the Act.
And now—in the tumult of this new Gilded Age—the tensions between preservation and the drive to take from the West have again taken center stage. After years of grassroots activism, a broad Indigenous coalition convinced the Obama administration to create Bears Ears National Monument in 2016, protecting archaeological sites and a living landscape of profound importance to Indigenous peoples.
Citing federal overreach and resource development, the Trump administration cut the monument by some 85% in 2017, a decision President Biden reversed in 2021. In July 2026, Trump went further, shrinking Bears Ears from 1.36 million acres to 121,096 and opening excluded lands to mining and mineral leasing.
When we preserve and protect our shared heritage, we create places of giving. These places provide us with wonder, knowledge, perspective, and a connection to those who came before. But the artifacts, minerals, and timber of these cherished places can be taken only once, and only for the benefit of those doing the taking.
As the Trump administration seeks to compromise the integrity of both national monuments and national parks for the benefit of a new generation of robber barons, we would do well to remember the lessons of the past. Protected and preserved, these monuments and parks can continue to give—to us, to our children, and to generations we will never know.
![]()
Learn More:
Harmon, David, Francis P. McManamon, and Dwight T. Pitcaithley, eds. The Antiquities Act: A Century of American Archaeology, Historic Preservation, and Nature Conservation. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 2006.
Righter, Robert W. “National Monuments to National Parks: The Use of the Antiquities Act of 1906.” Western Historical Quarterly 20, no. 3 (August 1989): 281–301.
Rothman, Hal K. America’s National Monuments: The Politics of Preservation. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1994.
Sellars, Richard West. “A Very Large Array: Early Federal Historic Preservation—The Antiquities Act, Mesa Verde, and the National Park Service Act.” Natural Resources Journal 47, no. 2 (Spring 2007): 267–328.
Squillace, Mark. “The Monumental Legacy of the Antiquities Act of 1906.” Georgia Law Review 37 (2003): 473–607.